📦 Shipping Notice for Out-of-State Orders

To ensure your bagels arrive as fresh as possible, all out-of-state orders must be placed by 6:00 PM (ET) on Fridays to be included in the following week's shipment.

Orders placed after 6:00 PM Friday will be shipped the following week to avoid delays or packages sitting in transit over the weekend.

Thank you for your understanding and for helping us get your bagels to you at their best!

1 3

Cheddar Bagels

Cheddar Bagels

$11.99 USD
$11.99 USD
Sale Sold out

Our Cheddar Bagels are kettle-boiled and topped with sharp cheddar that bakes into a golden, savory crust.

Flavor & Texture

Rich cheddar flavor with a crisp cheese exterior and dense, chewy New York style interior.

Best Ways to Enjoy

  • Ham, egg & cheddar
  • Grilled bagel melts
  • Cream cheese & chives
  • Breakfast sandwiches

Delivered Nationwide

Enjoy authentic New York style cheddar bagels delivered nationwide. Store frozen for long-term freshness and toast before serving.

View full details